NBA News From The Athletic

The Athletic: Josh Hart’s mental battle and path back to himself

Hart opens up about his mental battle, shooting struggles and efforts to rediscover his confidence.

Josh Hart is battling through a difficult stretch on and off the court.

Editor’s Note: Read more NBA coverage from The Athletic here. The views on this page do not necessarily reflect the views of the NBA or its teams. 

***

TORONTO — Tuesday night, in the aftermath of another New York Knicks victory in Toronto, Josh Hart was asked a question that would force him to think back to the player he wants to be again — and not the one, by his own admission, that he is right now.

The question, at its core, was rooted in appreciation for the career Hart has carved out, one that helped turn the Knicks back into a respectable franchise and end a 53-year championship drought just a few months ago. Hart’s physicality, IQ and relentlessness have long made him one of the NBA’s best role players. When he’s going, Hart is the glue that turns all of New York’s pieces into a valuable picture.

The question posed to Hart was about the secrets to winning the mental game against an opponent, through the qualities that have made Hart a 10-year veteran and NBA champion.

“I wish I could tell you,” Hart said. “The mental battle has been kicking my a– for a couple of weeks now.”


Hart, in the midst of one of the toughest stretches of his career, told reporters in Indiana last week that he was “not in a good headspace.” The 31-year-old didn’t elaborate on its cause, what it entailed or how he’s taking steps to overcome this mental hurdle. Following Tuesday’s game against the Raptors, a game that Hart said was a “step in the right direction” and one in which he made a series of critical plays to help New York get the win, Hart was open about what he’s been going through.

“I’m struggling to shoot the ball, but it’s one of those things where you start looking at the negatives and that’s all you see,” Hart said. “You don’t see some of the positives. Then it’s a snowball effect. One thing happens, and you’re trying to get yourself out of a hole that you’re not giving yourself the ability to get out of. It’s about playing with that joyful spirit, looking at things half full instead of half empty.”

Sometimes people forget that athletes are people, too. They have vicious loops, like you and me. They, too, are catastrophizing little details, allowing them to compound into one massive wave of doubt.

Hart, the player and person, wears his emotions on his sleeve. You know when he’s happy. You know when he’s mad. That same quality, though, can lead to Hart being his own worst enemy. He’s his own toughest critic.

Hart, admittedly, hasn’t been playing with the pleasure that his profession carries at its essence. It’s a sport, one that he gets paid nicely to play. He’s in the business of entertainment. Every day he makes someone’s day with a simple interaction. But it is still a job that can impact how his family lives, where it lives and can end at the snap of a finger. Hart’s irritability with himself and the situation he’s been in has radiated off him as he’s tried to navigate this difficult time, which has him shooting career-low numbers across the board and playing the least amount of minutes he has in five seasons. It’s hard to miss if you’re watching because it’s been hard for him to hide it.


The first step in Hart finding himself again as a player has been changing his outlook, which was evident in Tuesday’s game. There was no slumping of the shoulders. His head didn’t drop, his chin didn’t touch his chest. He didn’t argue with refs. He apologized to his teammates anytime he made a mistake. Tuesday’s performance wasn’t vintage Hart, but it had moments of that guy. There was a clutch basket. There was a hustle play to earn the Knicks an extra possession. There was a quick, decisive pass to a teammate for him to get a shot. In a matter of 90 seconds, Hart played all of his hits.

Afterward, Hart could have sulked over the fact that he only had five points, went 1-of-4 from 3 or that he, once again, wasn’t on the floor in crunch time. Instead, he chose to focus on his process of getting better.

“For me, this (rough patch) is a little harder because I’m trying to get the mental aspect right and the physical aspect right,” Hart said. “It can be easier when you’re just dealing with one of those things. … I’m battling both of those things. I’m trying to give myself a little bit of grace with that.”

Hart’s shooting — which he puts a lot of work into and even asked his coach, Mike Brown, to hire a shooting coach — has taken a big step back from where it was last season, when he knocked down a career-best 41.3 percent of his 3s. It’s taken a hit on his confidence and played a part in the Knicks’ starting lineup not being as dominant as it has the potential to be.

On top of that, Hart’s body is giving him trouble. Not only is one of his fingers slanted nearly at a 90-degree angle — if he got it fixed, he’d likely not be able to play basketball anymore — but he also dealt with a calf injury in September that kept him from preparing for training camp. He was then troubled by an ankle injury. He’s had knee issues in the past.


Around a year ago, Hart was in a similar rut. Following a game early in the regular season, which was the latest in a series of tough performances for the veteran, Hart was questioning his role as a starter. He thought to himself, “Am I a–? Do I suck as a basketball player?” Hart has gone through challenging periods before and came out on the other side.

There are examples for him to call back on that he can use as encouragement to overcome his challenges this time around, right?

“When you’re in the middle of it, there’s not much that can really help,” Hart said. “At the end of the day … today, I think I had a little bit better of a spirit.”

Hart’s professional career is at an interesting stage. He has a team option for next season, meaning the Knicks can make him a free agent if they choose to. Also, New York is 8-6 and not exactly taking the basketball world by storm. The team will have to make some tough roster decisions in the near future because of how much money the starting lineup makes and the owner not wanting to go into the second apron.


Even with all of that going on, Hart said that isn’t the cause of his battle within himself. It’s more of an add-on. It’s natural to think about how his performance might impact his future. The contract situation might not be the root of what he’s going through, but it’s a compound effect. If this happens and this happens and this happens, then maybe this happens.

We’ve all been there.

“That’s the low-hanging fruit,” Hart said when asked if his contract situation is getting to him. “Some of those things are amplified because you’re in a contract year, essentially. It’s human nature for it to be in the back of your mind, but when you start focusing on those things, negative outcomes happen.”

The best version of Hart gives the Knicks a better shot at repeating as champions. He’s a unique talent that can swing a game or series without needing a single play called for him. More important than that, though, is what New York needs: Hart finding peace within himself, for himself.

It’s hard to help others before helping yourself. It’s impossible to pour from an empty cup.

***

James L. Edwards III is a senior writer for The Athletic covering the New York Knicks. Previously, he covered the Detroit Pistons at The Athletic for seven seasons and, before that, was a reporter for the Lansing State Journal, where he covered Michigan State and high school sports. Follow James on X @JLEdwardsIII.

Latest